29 Palms Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on 29 Palms bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes in 29 Palms courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: Spoiling a Newborn

who's talking here?

MrsH 1
Kerry 2
Ces1 1
Dimples 1
RaeRie 3
Gold Canyon Momma 1
Jane Doe 1
CareBear 1
Mary Swanson 1
AuroraBorednZealous 2
BoxTop Hero 2
*MarineWifey311* 1
Jennin29Palms 8
kElJoY 10
Shineonyoucrazydiamond 2
on a need to know basis 4
Kara 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

POLL: Spoiling a Newborn

It's pretty ugly around here. I'm "nuts" and "crazy" for holding my little one (3.5 weeks) too much. I'm told by the man with no other kids I need to let her cry and put her on a schedule. This is how I cared for the other 4. I have no plans on changing anything I do. I'm curious if I'm the only "crazy" out there.

You can't spoil a newborn Vote
 
 80.6% (25)
Schedules should be started from Day 1 Vote
 
 12.9% (4)
Everyone let's their baby cry (his quote!) Vote
 
 6.5% (2)
Jennin29Palms --- 15 years ago -

It's pretty ugly around here. I'm "nuts" and "crazy" for holding my little one (3.5 weeks) too much. I'm told by the man with no other kids I need to let her cry and put her on a schedule. This is how I cared for the other 4. I have no plans on changing anything I do. I'm curious if I'm the only "crazy" out there. 

Kara --- 15 years ago -

8 weeks is the time to begin scheduling...look up Becoming Babywise.

This book is ingenious. 

kElJoY --- 15 years ago -

I'm told by the man with no other kids I need to let her cry and put her on a schedule.

Do you really want ME to respond to this...I voted you can't spoil a newborn. 

MrsH --- 15 years ago -

Thats too young to let a baby cry it out, IMO. Babies at that age cry to satisfy their needs and comfort from a parent is something that every child NEEDS. 

Kerry --- 15 years ago -

you can spoil a newborn and baby, my hubby is in that process, going to have to kick his butt since he isn't the one home all day. 

on a need to know basis --- 15 years ago -

My baby is spoiled, he always wants me to hold him and he is 4 months now. 

on a need to know basis --- 15 years ago -

I voted that you cant spoil a newborn. 

BoxTop Hero --- 15 years ago -

You can't spoil a newborn. even a FTM knows that.

Trust your motherly instincts, always. You are not crazy. he is.

6 months is when spoiling becomes an issue according to a few books I've read.


And as for a schedule?! I didn't get one of those down-pat until 9 months. 

Jennin29Palms --- 15 years ago -

I think what really brain washed him was the fact she was in the NICU for a week. They have them on this perfect every 3 hours schedule. She had to be under the lights and could only be out for 30 minutes every 3 hours. Now she's no longer super sleepy and acts like a real baby. 

RaeRie (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I'm told by the man with no other kids I need to let her cry and put her on a schedule.

Do you really want ME to respond to this


Oh, BIG ditto from me.

You can't spoil a newborn. There is a reason they cry. 

RaeRie (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

And you don't put your kid on a schedule at that young of an age. They put YOU on one, lol. 

kElJoY --- 15 years ago -

My baby is spoiled, he always wants me to hold him and he is 4 months now.

That's not spoiled...babies are supposed to be held. 

BoxTop Hero --- 15 years ago -

And you don't put your kid on a schedule at that young of an age. They put YOU on one, lol.
AMEN. 

on a need to know basis --- 15 years ago -

That's not spoiled...babies are supposed to be held.

I know Kel lol, you want to come hold him so I can get some work done. 

RaeRie (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

My baby is spoiled, he always wants me to hold him and he is 4 months now.

And that's why baby slings are the best inventions ever, lol. Not to mention I'm a heck of a lot stronger from carrying my daughter everywhere when she was tiny. Unintentional bonus. :) 

on a need to know basis --- 15 years ago -

And that's why baby slings are the best inventions ever


I need to get one still 

Kerry --- 15 years ago -

That's not spoiled...babies are supposed to be held.

Yes they are suppose to be held but not all day and night though JMO. My mother in law did that with my daughter and she would never go down anywhere always wanted someone hold her all the way up to a year old. I get onto my husband that if my newborn is sleeping to put him down somewhere. When he is awake then he can be held. 

kElJoY --- 15 years ago -

When he is awake then he can be held.

Well that I agree with. 

AuroraBorednZealous --- 15 years ago -

My hubs complained that I would hog our son & he would feel left out if I breastfed our son & I got extra bonding time. He was scheduled to deploy 3 weeks after our son was born so I pumped & he bottle fed our son. 

CareBear --- 15 years ago -

You can't spoil a newborn. There is a reason they cry.

And you don't put your kid on a schedule at that young of an age. They put YOU on one, lol.

Agree 100%! 

Jennin29Palms --- 15 years ago -

My hubs complained that I would hog our son & he would feel left out if I breastfed our son & I got extra bonding time. He was scheduled to deploy 3 weeks after our son was born so I pumped & he bottle fed our son.

I wish he was going somewhere! No this all stemmed from me getting her down the other night. Of course 5 minutes later she started screaming and I was cleaning up (God forbid someone help me) and he was sitting there watching TV eating ice cream. Didn't even flinch. I gave him a few minutes before I flipped out. I can see not jumping every time they fuss. But when she's screaming? He's not bonding with her, he's too lazy. To top it off his mother is coming for 2 weeks and we aren't even on speaking terms. This is going to be fun. 

Jane Doe --- 15 years ago -

You can't spoil a baby. No matter the age. They are all different and their wants are different. Needs are basic. And he can't tell you how to parent your daughter just as you can't force him to be the perfect dad. Esp since it's his first newborn. Maybe having his mom will shed some light on where his parental instincts come from?
PS you always know you can come here :] I even have baby stuff lol. 

Jennin29Palms --- 15 years ago -

Maybe having his mom will shed some light on where his parental instincts come from?

I worry the bad advice is coming from her. We shall see. I'll be over soon. Don't want to share my germs! 

kElJoY --- 15 years ago -

My experience with men is that they generally tend to treat their wives how they saw their fathers treat their mothers.

Good luck Jennin. 

Jennin29Palms --- 15 years ago -

He didn't have a father growing up. He doesn't seem close with his mother. I don't think he was held enough as a child! 

kElJoY --- 15 years ago -

Oh. So maybe he doesn't know how to be a husband and father. Get him a book. 

Jennin29Palms --- 15 years ago -

Just ordered 2 off Amazon. He responded well to the Bradley Book for childbirth. I even got nightly back rubs like the book said! Hopefully Dr Sears can knock some sense in him. 

kElJoY --- 15 years ago -

Good luck girl. 

AuroraBorednZealous --- 15 years ago -

No this all stemmed from me getting her down the other night. Of course 5 minutes later she started screaming and I was cleaning up (God forbid someone help me) and he was sitting there watching TV eating ice cream. Didn't even flinch. I gave him a few minutes before I flipped out. I can see not jumping every time they fuss. But when she's screaming? He's not bonding with her, he's too lazy.


That's just sad. Is he a young first time father? Sometimes with age comes wisdom (not in all cases). He just doesn't seem to have his priorities in order if he's not willing to be a contributing factor in your lives. He needs a reality check quick! 

Shineonyoucrazydiamond --- 15 years ago -

And as for a schedule?! I didn't get one of those down-pat until 9 months.

I JUST started a scuedule at 12 months for my baby! lol 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
children

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

29 Palms Underground