29 Palms Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on 29 Palms bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes in 29 Palms courtesy of Military Real Estate!

YUCCA VALLEY MAN FACES MURDER CHARGE AFTER VICTIM DIES, 30 YEARS LATER

who's talking here?

Mari 11
The Paparazzi 3
Mustluvpits 10
Justatouchofcute 1
Kay1024 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Mustluvpits --- 15 years ago -

A Yucca Valley man, one of two who did prison time for the attempted murder of an Orange County sheriff's deputy 30 years ago, has now been charged with murder after the victim died of his injuries. Deputy Ira Essoe's legs were amputated as a result of the November 1980 shooting. He died early this year, doctors say due to the old bullet wounds. David Knick, 54, of Yucca Valley was arrested Thursday after deputies and a Sheriff’s helicopter swarmed his Yucca Valley home. Robert Strong, 55, of Riverside was also arrested. They had already been convicted of the November 1980 attempted murder of Essoe, who was shot and paralyzed in a mall parking lot. Knick had been convicted of attempted murder, auto theft, possession of a firearm by a felon, and two felony counts each of assault with a deadly weapon and auto burglary. He received 16 years and eight months in state prison and served about nine years. The shooting left Essoe paralyzed and suffering for three decades, serious medical complications had resulted in the amputation of both of his legs. If convicted, Knick and Strong each face a maximum sentence of 25 years to life in state prison. They are being held in lieu of $1-million bail and face arraignment Friday.

I think this is sssooo stupid. They already been charged. Whats this world coming too. 

Kay1024 --- 15 years ago -

I agree. I realize it was attempted, and now the man finally died. But they still served their time for their actions. 

Justatouchofcute --- 15 years ago -

I think this is sssooo stupid. They already been charged. Whats this world coming too.

They were convicted of ATTEMPTED murder but now being charged with murder. But yes special nonetheless. 

Mari (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

They were charged and served time for attempted murder, the gentleman died from complications of the bullets, true 30-years later, but if they hadn't shot him, there would be no complications from the bullets and they wouldn't have had an issue. The Statute of Limitations must not have run out. 

Kay1024 --- 15 years ago -

I don't think they should be charged again. I realize the man died. But I honestly don't think they committed murder, they TRIED, and failed. and now he died 30 years later due to complications of injuries. 

Mustluvpits --- 15 years ago -

I'm sure Statue of Limitations are gone...then they sgould give them there served time back . The piont is this...they have already been charged. period. 

Kay1024 --- 15 years ago -

Yes, they say he "suffered" but did he really??? How many times do lawyers tell their clients "plea criminal insanity" they twist things too. How exactly did he "suffer" 

Mari (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

In California, there is no statute of limitations on murder or embezzlement, so it doesn't matter how long ago the crime happened. You cannot be charged twice for the same crime, but attempted murder and murder are two different crimes, and without a statute of limitations, this was probably bound to happen, especially since he was a double amputee and what did the bullets do to his internal organs (we don't have all of those details). 

Mustluvpits --- 15 years ago -

So, you are telling me this...4 example....

back in 2001 I was hit by a drunk driver at 147 mph (I was outside the vehicle changing a tire) and all the medical issues I have--that will end up killing me-- my husband can sue even if i dont die for another 50 yrs???? 

Kay1024 --- 15 years ago -

Well from what I'm understanding from previous posts (I could be wrong, I don't know everything about law) he could maybe be charged for homicide, not attempted (and then eventually succeeded) murder. 

Mustluvpits --- 15 years ago -

LOL, I think whats been done in the pas is time served. My husband knows to not do anything apon my request.

If the law told *most* people to jump off a bridge....there would be lines. 

The Paparazzi --- 15 years ago -

my question is how old was the cop? if he was in his 80's then it could be argued that maybe just plain ol age was the final cause of death

I personally think its alittle on the BS side 

Mari (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

A Yucca Valley man, one of two who did prison time for the attempted murder of an Orange County sheriff's deputy 30 years ago, has now been charged with murder after the victim died of his injuries.

The article says they did prison time for attempted murder, and has now been charged with murder. I think the difference between homicide and murder is the intent of the perpetrator. 

Mustluvpits --- 15 years ago -

ok, then, what was the intent of the drunk driver that hit me..... 

Mari (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I'd want to know the extent of his injuries, i.e if he suffered kidney damage and was on dialysis for 30 years and eventually died of kidney failure, then I can see it. They must be able to tie his injuries directly to the bullets in order to make this claim, the defense attorney's are going to have a hay day... 

Mustluvpits --- 15 years ago -

I getcha, Mari...It all just depends... 

The Paparazzi --- 15 years ago -

i.e if he suffered kidney damage and was on dialysis for 30 years and eventually died of kidney failure, then I can see it.


and prove that he hadnt had ONE drink in those last 30 years......

I dont think this suit will go to far, there are to many ifs and holes that I can foresee coming up! 

Mari (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

ok, then, what was the intent of the drunk driver that hit me..... 

Depends on what the prosecutor wants to go for, and whether he/she feels they can make a solid case, I would venture to guess. I know the jury I just sat on, it was the prosecutions responsibility to prove intent, the defense wasn't there to prove the perpetrators innocence, it was crazy, totally NOT like you see on TV. 

Mari (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

and prove that he hadnt had ONE drink in those last 30 years......

I would think a kidney that's suffered kidney damage from alcohol, would look very different from one that a bullet has shattered, but who knows? 

Mari (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

Silly, when were you hit by a DD? Were you able to walk away? How scary. 

Mustluvpits --- 15 years ago -

I bet. sorry you have jury duty. our case didnt make it to court. he had no insurance so since that we had to come up with 10 thousand dollars just to take him to court so we couldnt.. 

The Paparazzi --- 15 years ago -


I would think a kidney that's suffered kidney damage from alcohol, would look very different from one that a bullet has shattered, but who knows?


ya, but if he had kidney damage from a bullet and then later drank, that would damage it further and may have been the real reason for death!!!!!!! 

Mustluvpits --- 15 years ago -

me and my hubs stopped to help someone with a flat on the side of 10 freeway back in 2001....lost the case due to himnot having insurance. i was in the hospital forever then PCS'd to CL three months later....i have alot of issues medicaly though. greatfull for trycare.... 

Mari (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

Oh, I'm done now, it went for 3 weeks, crazy, but interesting once you get into the case. Wait, what happened to him? He had no insurance, did he just walk away? 

Mari (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

me and my hubs stopped to help someone with a flat on the side of 10 freeway back in 2001....lost the case due to himnot having insurance. i was in the hospital forever then PCS'd to CL three months later....i have alot of issues medicaly though. greatfull for trycare.... 

Wow, so, no one held him accountable? 

Mustluvpits --- 15 years ago -

yes he got one night in the drunk tank and thats all. they never charged him for the loaded weapon or the fact this was his 3rd DUI. ive been fighting for SSD since then and FINALLY go to court in JAN 

Mari (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

Wow, seems like someone dropped the ball on that one. I know there are attorney's that you tell them about your case and they'll decide if they think they have a case, and if they don't get anything for you, you don't owe them anything. 

Mustluvpits --- 15 years ago -

i have one of those. they said as soon as they found out he had no insurance he cant help me. it would cost 10 thousand the retain another to go after him-----so my life wasnt worth any money value.....sad 

Mari (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I know right? I guess the guy had no house to go after either. I don't understand why he didn't serve some time for that, must have been some silly loophole someplace. Well I hope things work out for you in January. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

29 Palms Underground