29 Palms Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on 29 Palms bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes in 29 Palms courtesy of Military Real Estate!

debate it here!

who's talking here?

cdub 6
meredith 2
KelJoY II 2
Dimples 6
CaNdYcAnE 4
RaeRie 1
Bitchy 3
yellowroseTX 5
Justatouchofcute 4
Nessa 1
JingleBells 2
Scrappy 4
laura loo 1
CareBear 1
sharpeilover22 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

CaNdYcAnE --- 16 years ago -

when did you start your child on whole milk? age or developmental stages? tell me what you did and why!!!! 

RaeRie (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

My munchkin didn't get cow's milk until she was a year old. Everything I researched and the Dr. told me to wait until then because the digestive track wouldn't be fully developed until a year old. But I am also very strict about what my munchkin eats and drinks. 

Justatouchofcute --- 16 years ago -

I started transitioning my daughter at 11 1/2 months. By the time she turned one she was on just whole milk. She was on 5 ounces of formula so for the first 3 days she got 1 once of whole milk mixed with 4 ounces of formula, then she got 2 ounces milk, with 3 ounces formula, so on and so forth. 

Dimples --- 16 years ago -

After a year old. That's what all the doctors say. Any time before that they aren't able to process the protein in cows milk 

yellowroseTX --- 16 years ago -

started my son at 1 year same reason as RaeRie 

Bitchy --- 16 years ago -

8 Mos to a year. 

CaNdYcAnE --- 16 years ago -

8 Mos to a year. yeah thats what i amthinking. My son doesnt wanna take his bottle anymore. he will drink a ounce and throw it. he eats all day long. 3 meals and 2 snacks. he eats lots of fruits and veggies and everything we eat for dinner. I think he will be fine to start on cows milk. He has GI issues and the dr had us start him early on everything juice at 2 months baby food at 3 and now he has two teeth and hes trying to walk away *tear* i wasnt really for whole milk but seems that whats may happen. Just wanted to know if anyone else was told to start their babies early! 

cdub --- 16 years ago -

one year is best bc of milk intolerances and allergies. 

Dimples --- 16 years ago -

If a doctor tells someone to start their baby on milk before a year old they should be reported....just saying 

CaNdYcAnE --- 16 years ago -

one year is best bc of milk intolerances and allergies. the dr said thats what there normal concerns are as well as enough iron and other vitamins. My son has problems going to the bathroom and the dr said to try a bottle of whole milk once a day and hes gone more often and its a softer stool. i think for his tummy problems this may be a good move. 

CaNdYcAnE --- 16 years ago -

If a doctor tells someone to start their baby on milk before a year old they should be reported.... reported? really? wow thats pretty harsh. Not all babies fit perfectly into every situation. SOme have health problems that require adjustments. that would saying that becasue my child isnt asmatic that you shouldn't give one that is breathing treatments. it may not be right for one but could be for another. 

Nessa --- 16 years ago -

I started transitioning my oldest 2 weeks before her 1st bday.. I first asked her doctor if it was okay to start and she said it was fine, but to give her regular milk just once or twice until a year.. once she got the taste she refused formula.. my middle and youngest were both a year old.. 

Scrappy --- 16 years ago -

I started to transition mine at around 11 months too. I mixed it half formula half milk so that they could get used to it. I just kept adding more milk than formula for a couple weeks until it was all milk. I found that going straight to whole milk caused extreme constipation in my first one. I have 4 kids and not one of them ever had any issues with the way I did it :) 

CareBear --- 16 years ago -

I've never heard of having a child start on cow's milk until after a year of age, and even then it was cow's milk cut with formula to slowly introduce it. Their tummies aren't able to break down the protein and enzymes in it, and it can make them very sick if you start it too soon. When I did daycare my boss and I weren't allowed by the federal food program to offer anything other than formula (or breast milk if the mother provided it) to the kids until they were 12 months or we had a doctor's note saying they could drink milk. 

Dimples --- 16 years ago -

No I don't think it's harsh. It's a known fact that a baby can't digest it properly before they are 12 months old. I'm extremely picky on what I give my children and at what age. If a child can't digest something at a certain age then I don't see the purpose of giving it to them especially if it may or can be harmful. 

Scrappy --- 16 years ago -

oh and some kids wont drink milk at all, my third child didnt like it. I worried because I thought they HAD to drink it to be healthy. My Dr said not to worry and that as long as he had plenty of fat in his diet it would be fine. 

cdub --- 16 years ago -

"There are several reasons to delay the introduction of cow's milk until your baby reaches his first birthday. Most important, a baby's digestive system can't digest cow's milk proteins. Cow's milk also has too much sodium, potassium, and chloride, which can tax your baby's kidneys. Even if his system could handle it, cow's milk doesn't have all the vitamins and minerals (especially vitamin E, zinc, and iron) that he needs for growth and development in his first year. Giving a baby cow's milk could even cause iron deficiency and internal bleeding. And it can increase his risk of an allergic reaction." 

cdub --- 16 years ago -

GI issues and the dr had us start him early on everything juice at 2 months baby food at 3 That's really odd. Colton still has GI issues, along with many others, and he was seen by many specialists at two childrens hospitals in two different states and they all said not to take him off formula bc he couldnt get the things he needed from solids or juice and juice can cause GI issues to be even worse and with intense GI issues their immune system is compromised and not getting proper nutrients the'll have a higher risk for getting sick. 

cdub --- 16 years ago -

going to the bathroom and the dr said to try a bottle of whole milk once a day and hes gone more often and its a softer stool there are other, safer options besides giving an 8 month old or younger whole milk for constipation. 

yellowroseTX --- 16 years ago -

GI issues you'd think that would be a reason to NOT start him on milk early... 

meredith --- 16 years ago -

i didn't start mine till around a year too but like you said all babies don't fit into the exact same mold. i think it comes down to what you and your dr feel best is for your baby. just like with my son because of heath problems in the past we decided to opt out of the rotovirus vaccine. yes, it could have turned out he got it or something like that but he didn't and i didn't want to risk losing my baby like i almost did once before that. you can always ask your dr about the extra vitamins they have for infants if you're concerned about that. 

Justatouchofcute --- 16 years ago -

GI issues you'd think that would be a reason to NOT start him on milk early... I personally think it would depend on the issue. My husband has SEVERE allergies to something in formula and my MIL could not breastfeed him so he was put on Ensure (the adult diatary supplement drink) from the time he was 2 months til he was a year. Every kid is different and only a doctor can determine what is best for that child. JMO 

cdub --- 16 years ago -

they have neocate which is given to very problematic children. thats what my son was put on. its like 150 for 4 small cans, but the kids who cant take anything can take this bc the proteins are broken down into digestive form already. 

Dimples --- 16 years ago -

all babies don't fit into the exact same mold. It has nothing to do with "every baby is different". 

meredith --- 16 years ago -

no but it may be a case of risk/benefit for that particular childs needs...which may not be the same for every child. once again i think it's all about what you and your dr think is best but do your own research as well so you're not going into it uninformed and you know the questions that need to be asked. 

Dimples --- 16 years ago -

I just don't see how it's worth the risk. Nothing about "a baby can't process the protein and it can harm the child" screams hey let me give it to them anyways. 

laura loo --- 16 years ago -

I have 2 kids.. one is 2 and I started giving her milk at 11 months. I was very cautious what I fed her. I remember getting mad at my MIL because she fed her pancakes when she was 4 months old.. soda when she was 6 months old. Yeah.. I have THAT mil. ugh. I never gave her any kind of soda til she turned 2. It irks me to see people feed their 2 year old coffee. Or 3 month old rice (long grain). Call me crazy.. i dunno. My 6 month old..same deal. My hubby gets mad at me because I'm "over protective." I just don't want to hurt their lil tummies, ya know? We had King as his pedi when he was born and of course, he left. His replacement.. at his last wellness said he was underweight. He was 4 months old and 14lbs... I'm sorry my baby isn't 20lbs at 4 months. Sorry for the rant.. people just irk me i suppose. 

JingleBells --- 16 years ago -

um.......imma keep my thoughts to myself...lol...crap when do babies start eating baby food? my son is 4 months and he is a hungry hostage..he is so greedy he cries after he sucks down a cereal/milk bottle... 

Scrappy --- 16 years ago -

I just don't see how it's worth the risk. Nothing about "a baby can't process the protein and it can harm the child" screams hey let me give it to them anyways.  Well they obviously must be able to since so many people do start to ween their kids on it at around 10 or 11 months old. We also give our kids vaccines because the risks are outweighed by the benefits but there are children that have died from vaccines. Im not saying its the same thing but I get why some are saying depending on the childs needs and conditions. Also there is a lot of information on the net and other wise that will argue both sides of EVERYTHING. Not all of it is backed with actual medical evidence. 

Scrappy --- 16 years ago -

this may sound completely dumb too lol but here is some food for thought if u have a preemie say 3 months early, when they are one you give them milk. Is that wrong too since technically they were born early and wouldnt have been one for another 3 months??? How does there system get affected?? 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

29 Palms Underground