29 Palms Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on 29 Palms bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes in 29 Palms courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Do you spank your kids?

who's talking here?

cdub 1
C0NTR0LL3DCHA0S 3
Dimples 1
alter ego 4
Rude Rudy 1
*Really*you*think*so* 1
Amapeli 1
RaeRie 1
kellyl 1
Justatouchofcute 3
Dionne 1
JingleBells 1
Krissy 1
Jane Doe 6
CareBear 1
abc123 1
Traviesa LOcOnA 1
sharpeilover22 4
Josie-R 1
that 1
michelle1 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

michelle1 --- 16 years ago -

I truly support the book by Dr Jack Hyles (How to raise Children). Anybody else read the book? When I was growing up in my birth country, children were regularly spanked. (Sure, there were some cases of domestic violence, but what country doesn't?- so pls don't say 'oh~~ it's child abuse, cuz it's not) So in general, both at home and in the school setting we were disciplined by the rod. Most of them grow up and become adults that respect elders and authority, though in recent trends because parents have adopted the newer ideas, young people have been growing more and more rebellious towards authority. Anyway when I was growing up I've never seen a child throw a fit or tantrum until I came to the United States. And for some reason most people have this frame of thought that (throwing a fit) is a regular part of development. So what's up moms? What do you do with your kids?  

sharpeilover22 --- 16 years ago -

And for some reason most people have this frame of thought that (throwing a fit) is a regular part of development. if i saw a kid that never in their life "threw a fit" or became upset over something i would wonder whats wrong...i guess im one of those that do see it as a normal part of development. 

Jane Doe --- 16 years ago -

When I see an adult NOT throw a fit in their life I'll believe it's not normal for kids to throw one. Heck I'm (I wont say my age) and I throw them now and again. Doesn't mean I need to be spanked. (Although hubs might wanna lol sorry had to) 

sharpeilover22 --- 16 years ago -

Doesn't mean I need to be spanked. (Although hubs might wanna lol sorry had to) haha i saw that coming from a mile away... 

Jane Doe --- 16 years ago -

haha i saw that coming from a mile away... Lol, I just got to it before Traviesa did! Lol. I have my beliefs but they are just that... mine. Not for others to judge. 

sharpeilover22 --- 16 years ago -

I have my beliefs but they are just that... mine. Not for others to judge i feel the same way, usually i wouldn't mind putting it out there anyway but i just dont have the energy for it tonight-im too tired lol maybe later. 

Jane Doe --- 16 years ago -

but i just dont have the energy for it tonight-im too tired lol maybe later. That's what I told my husband when he wanted to 'spank' me hahahaha I'm so kidding but I really had to! 

sharpeilover22 --- 16 years ago -

lol! its time for me to go to bed now...JD-enjoy your night doing whatever it is you may be doing :) 

Jane Doe --- 16 years ago -

Ew I'm not Traviesa! Lol Have a good night :) I'll be turning in soon too. Wanted to watch Army Wives before I went to bed. Done now :) 

michelle1 --- 16 years ago -

if i saw a kid that never in their life "threw a fit" or became upset over something i would wonder whats wrong... there's a difference between getting upset/angry and throwing a tantrum. you ever see those kids who scream and kick their feet at the malls because they are not getting what they want? that's what I'm talking about. That's utter disrespect for your parents, and utter lack of discipline. 

Jane Doe --- 16 years ago -

Ok here goes. And remember this is MY approach to MY child only. I dicipline my son. In my own ways. Sometimes a swat on the hand if he touches something or a smack on the bum (no harder than you would pat someone's back) to get his attention. However I talk to him before hand and let him know that what he's doing is a no no. I do NOT agree with parents diciplining a child that isn't theirs. I do NOT want someone to touch my child or act as their parent because he already has a mother and father. I was raised getting spanked however it wasn't this beating. It was punishment for doing something wrong and it was as the bible taught it. Do I think it's right? I dunno. I do know however that I was taught respect and getting my butt smacked didn't teach me that. My parents talking to me and teaching me is how I learned manners and morals. Not to mention watching them apply it to their lives. As parents our kids are sponges and learn from us. If we do bad and then punish them for doing the same thing we are just perpetuating the cycle of defiance. Sorry so long. 

RaeRie (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

I do know however that I was taught respect and getting my butt smacked didn't teach me that. My parents talking to me and teaching me is how I learned manners and morals Agreed. I can count the number of times I can remember getting spanked on one hand. I don't spank, personally. Am I completely against it and consider it child abuse? No. I just don't think it's the right tactic for me. 

Justatouchofcute --- 16 years ago -

Sometimes a swat on the hand if he touches something or a smack on the bum (no harder than you would pat someone's back) to get his attention. However I talk to him before hand and let him know that what he's doing is a no no. I totally agree with this. My daughter has been smacked on the hand numerous times, but she also gets 2 warnings before hand. It is not my first reaction for discipline and it isn't always the best choice. The punishment must fit the crime in my book. do NOT agree with parents diciplining a child that isn't theirs. I do NOT want someone to touch my child or act as their parent because he already has a mother and father. Here is where I have a question Jane Doe... (please don't think I am picking on you, just want to share a difference in opinion) If you were watching someone else's child and they hit yours would you discipline them?? If one of my friends got on to my daughter because she was doing something wrong I would not complain. I am in a playgroup and some of us are very close. If my daughter were to do something, such as harm another child, and I either didn't catch it or was not around to handle it I would totally expect my friends to put her in time out! She has to know that even though mommy isn't around she can't get away with murder. Now if a friend of mine spanked or smacked my child that is a WHOLE different story! But simple punishment such as time out or a talking to is totally acceptable. 

Rude Rudy --- 16 years ago -

Heck, I'll spank anyone who wants it....LOL...Especially you Crazy C!!!! 

*Really*you*think*so* --- 16 years ago -

I spank, its not my first reaction, but I do. There is a difference in abuse and spanking. I dont think spanking teaches respect, I think it is a good form of discipline though, as long as you stay in the boundaries. What is wrong with todays children is people are to interested in being there childrens friend instead of parent. Each child is different and different things work better than others. With my oldest the thing that works the best is physical work. With his dad deployed we have gone through some ruff patches and nothing seemed to work including spanking. One day he made me so mad, I needed him out of my face I told him to go run up and down the stairs tell I said to stop. And I was shocked that after that he had a major change in attitude. Not only is it good for him, but it works. 

Justatouchofcute --- 16 years ago -

Each child is different and different things work better than others. With my oldest the thing that works the best is physical work. With his dad deployed we have gone through some ruff patches and nothing seemed to work including spanking. One day he made me so mad, I needed him out of my face I told him to go run up and down the stairs tell I said to stop. And I was shocked that after that he had a major change in attitude. Not only is it good for him, but it works. This is so true! It takes time and patience to see what works best for your child! This may sound horrible but when my friends son would act up she would squirt him with a water bottle. Nothing else worked, but that got his attention and stopped the negative behavior. 

alter ego --- 16 years ago -

straight into the fire i go.... totally bypassing the pan....... my kids get spanked. it is few and far between, but they do. and i will let you know now that if my kids ever got a wild hair up their a$$ and tried to step up to me, they would get put down quicker than you could blink. i will never ever ever be one of those moms that gets called a b*tch by her kids and says "now now tommy, thats not nice, i think you need a time out". im not saying that i beat my children. i am often heard telling my children that they need to go to their room and contemplate their situation. but i have also looked my kids dead in the face and told them that they needed to get away from me so that i could contemplate mine. i will admit that more than once i have looked at my kids and told them that they needed to leave me alone because i felt like i just wanted to beat them. as a child that was abused, there is a fine line between discipline and abuse. the monster within that is created when someone has been abused is a force to be reckoned with, and i am all to aware of the monster within me. my kids know that i will never abuse them, and long before i raise a hand to them, i will but some distance between me and them to cool off. i have never ever spanked my kids when i have been angry. but oooohhh they have seen me angry. it is the anger within me that my kids fear coming out, not me. (they have seen momma bear come out to protect them, and they both say they never want to be the target of that kind of rage) ;) that said, when you do something someone tells you to do because your afraid of what will happen if you dont - your acting out of fear not out of respect for that person. 

alter ego --- 16 years ago -

Each child is different and different things work better than others. my neighbors 5 year old believes i will bake her into a pie if she isnt good for her mom. my children used to honestly believe that if they misbehave in public i would duct tape them to the bathroom wall. (this threat no longer works on the same neighbors oldest son who now desires to be duct taped to a random wall or ceiling cause he thinks it would be fun. 

Amapeli --- 16 years ago -

only on occasion... mostly I take away his Bakugan and that is torture enough, but hes a pretty good kid and my 1yr old is too young to even know what its for, soooo, A harsh, no and he backs off 

Josie-R --- 16 years ago -

I will swat my son on the butt if he is really bad but usually he's not. He doesn't really do things that I feel constitute a spanking. He will act up sometimes if he hasn't had a nap but it's nothing major. He's only two though so I still have a long way to go. 

Jane Doe --- 16 years ago -

If you were watching someone else's child and they hit yours would you discipline them?? To answer this: NO, I tell them not to hit but it is never my place to put a hand on another child. Their parents may be trying the NO approach. It's the least aggressive (when I say it anyways) and my son would just walk away anyways. I didn't teach him to he just does it. LIke fighting isn't in his playbook. 

kellyl --- 16 years ago -

It depends... I don't spank my youngest mostly because she is very stubborn and probably wouldn't care (and *I* feel she is too young) and laugh at me. My 5 year old has to REALLY push it for me to consider spanking. I was raised with spanking as punishment, but it generally went too far as my stepfather has extreme anger issues (and took it all out on me - nice). So I'm trying my damndest to NOT spank out of reaction, it's more out of "have run out of options". We do time out, counting, two warnings (sometimes three). I think spanking is FINE if it's not a main form of "punishment". For us, it's the very last resort. 

C0NTR0LL3DCHA0S --- 16 years ago -

there's a difference between getting upset/angry and throwing a tantrum. you ever see those kids who scream and kick their feet at the malls because they are not getting what they want? Most of that behavior comes from either being hungry, tired, both. Or in some cases it is the lack of complete schedule and routine in the family. It is in fact very normal for a young child, 1,2,3 to throw a fit that seems out of control. At that age they do not know how to express their wants or needs any other way. But I have found that if you intervene early and teach them to breath and communicate it will help to eliminate these horrific encounters. Spanking is a short lived, quick solution. In most cases. Yes, I have used it on my children and so far they don't appear to be totally mentally unstable. (like some suggest) For our family the best approach is making them accountable. Regardless of their age. Everything they do has a choice. It is up to them to stop, think about, and make the choice they think would have the best results. example. My child does not want to do their homework. When it is time to turn it in, they are sad because they don't get rewarded like the rest. So, the next week when we discuss doing homework, they are ready to get it done so they too can see the positive outcome. Obviously, this involves us teaching them way more than another approach might, and certainly can bring more tears for mom, but for me it is totally worth it. I could sit there and yell or force them to do it, but that is draining for us all. And really shows a lack of respect on both parties. My job is to raise them into functioning, respectable, responsible adults. I have only 18 years to do it. And yes, I do help with any task that needs help. As long as they try it by themselves first. 

alter ego --- 16 years ago -

I have used it on my children and so far they don't appear to be totally mentally unstable. (like some suggest) girl, with you for a mom, its bound to happen whether you spank or not.......j/k lmao sorry, it was to easy to pass up lol 

Dionne --- 16 years ago -

Well i suck at linking crap sorry!!! This was just on the home page on yahoo and thought it was a sign LOL http://news.yahoo.com/s/time/20100412/hl_time/08599198101900 

C0NTR0LL3DCHA0S --- 16 years ago -

Oh goodness, have you just lowered yourself! No more going out in the sun. You are better than that. 

Dimples --- 16 years ago -

Didn't read this all but wanted to respond. I can count on one hand how many times I've spanked my kids. In my household timeouts and different levels of timeouts work great. I really don't have a need to spank my kids. As for tantrums. I do believe it's a normal kid thing. Every child has at least had a handful of tantrums and I don't believe its them being disrespectful. Tantrums are based on either the child being tired, not being able to express themself to an adult, yes being spoiled, etc. There are many reasons for a child to have a tantrum. It's our job as parents to teach our children not only how to express themselves but how to behave. And if they do have a tantrum in public then we as parents need to intervene and learn how to react. When my children throw a tantrum you bet my butt I stop what we are doing and walk out. It's not ok behavior but most times can't be helped. 

JingleBells --- 16 years ago -

yes, and IM a PROUD Spanker...I can tesitify MY kids have never threw a fit.......EVER...I also take toys away and actually just recently I threw all their toys away and gave sum away..They thought I was joking..lol...SChool will be #1 b4 anything.... 

CareBear --- 16 years ago -

I do NOT agree with parents diciplining a child that isn't theirs. I do NOT want someone to touch my child or act as their parent because he already has a mother and father. Ditto. If someone were to ever put their hand on my child you can bet your butt that whoever did it would be sorry. I would never touch someone else's child because I believe that it is up to the parents to discipline them how they choose- not me. Now, if my child were in daycare, that's another story. I would still never, ever, be okay with physical punishment, but time out is fine, as long as it's not an excessive amount of time, and it fits the "crime". I've worked at two daycares (managing one) so I can see how not disciplining the children somehow would just create chaos. In my opinion, time out in a childcare setting is okay, and that's it. I saw my ex-boss smack a child's hand once and I nearly lost it on her (after the kids were napping, of course, lol)- that's soooo not her place to do that. As far as spanking goes, I believe that it should be a last resort. I don't want my kids to think that if they mess up, they're just going to be spanked. I would rather hold them accountable for their actions. For example: if they hurt a friend, they will be responsible for apologizing and maybe even making them a card or something saying that they're sorry. If they broke something, they'll fix it or work to replace it. The only time that I think spanking would be something I would consider is if my kid swore at me or called me a foul name. I definitely will not just be one of those parents that puts up with their child disrespecting them like that. My mom didn't- I called her a b!tch once and after the spanking I got, I knew better than to do it again. As far as tantrums go- I think that they're totally normal to an extent. And, there's a difference between a child throwing a tantrum because they've been told 'no', than throwing one because they're distressed somehow (tired, hungry, etc.). 

C0NTR0LL3DCHA0S --- 16 years ago -

I do NOT agree with parents diciplining a child that isn't theirs. I do NOT want someone to touch my child or act as their parent because he already has a mother and father. Anyone that is watching my child or responsible for my child, certainly shouldn't put their hands on them. Yes, I then would flip on them. But I completely disagree with the rest of this sentence. I can not watch my child 24/7. And when I am not around, or he is in the care of another adult I would hope that the adult would be responsible enough to address an issue that would need to be addressed. How else does the child learn to respect adults? You can force them to say "sir" and "ma'am" but unless they learn to listen and respond respectfully when an adult speaks to them how do they learn about actions and consequence? If I see a child doing something that they shouldn't be doing I approach them and try to understand why they felt the need to do it in the first place? It's a great feeling to be able to communicate with your own and other people's children. They then learn to repect you and want to be the "good" child they know they can be because it makes everyone proud of them. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

children
parenting

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

29 Palms Underground